Whew, I think I've put together about as robust a bibliography as I can manage on the history of psychoactive bindweeds for part of a monograph that I'm working on (about 140 sources... I imagine that's going to grow quite a bit when I get to tackling the chemistry). I've condensed my notes into a chronology to help organize my thoughts in the writing process, and figured others might find it interesting as well (I've cited all the information below, but don't yet have the actual bibliography in an easily-postable format... sorry... all you get for now is the author and year of publication).
One of the things that I found most interesting was that Wasson at one point considered a bindweed with ergot alkaloids as a candidate for
soma (many sources indicate that the original
soma was a sort of creeper vine), but abandoned the notion since no such plant was known to occur in India at the time... and apparently he never picked the notion back up even when
Argyreia nervosa (indigenous to India despite being popularly known as Hawaiian baby woodrose) was found to contain massive amounts of lysergic acid derivatives!
Conquest-Era References (see above for details)
1547-1569 - Bernardino de Sahagún
1571-1578 - Franisco Hernández
1574-1576 - Diego Durán
1590 - José de Acosta
1629 - Hernándo Ruiz de Alarcón
c. 1629 - Pedro Ponce
1634 - Bartolomé de Alva
1656 - Jacinto de la Serna
1780 - Francisco Javier Clavijero
Contemporary-Era References1854, 1888 - Oliva and León recognize ololiuhqui to be convolvulaceous. (León 1888; Oliva 1854)
1897 - Urbina identifies ololiuhqui as
Ipomoea sidaefolia [=
Turbina corymbosa] (Urbina 1897; Urbina 1903)
1911 - Hartwich rejects Urbina's identification, believing ololiuqui to be a solanaceous plant (Hartwich 1911)
1915 - Stafford argues that ololiuhqui can't be convolvulaceous since no bindweeds are known to be psychoactive. He asserts that it must be
Datura meteloides; much of the botanical world accepts his mistake as fact for decades (Stafford 1915; Schultes & Hofmann 1980)
1919, 1929 - Blas Pablo Reko observes the use of
T. corymbosa seeds in Oaxaca (including under the name
ololuc), and reports the people who drink the infusion of the seeds enter a somnambulent state of intoxication (Reko 1919; Reko 1929)
1932 - Cerna suggests ololiuhqui might be the seeds of a narcotic variety of poppies (Cerna 1932)
1934 - Blas Pablo Reko becomes the first non-indigenous person known to have consumed the seeds (Reko 1934). He does not perceive any psychoactivity after ingesting "a handful", but there are strong indications he did not grind the seeds (Osmond 1955; Ott 1996)
1935 - Ergonovine is isolated... but from ergot, not bindweed seeds (Dudley & Moir 1935; Kharasch & Legault 1935; Stoll & Burckhardt; Thompson 1935). As a result, many of the active chemicals from the bindweeds would be known as synthetic products before being rediscovered in the 60s (Hofmann 1963)
1936 - Parsons reports that the Zapotecs refer to the seeds of
I. violacea as 'badoh negro', but does not mention their being employed in any ritual contexts (Parsons 1936)
1937 - First chemical analysis
T. corymbosa seeds was performed by Santesson, who recieved the seeds from Reko. He was unable to isolate crystalline products, but found an ethanolic extract of the seeds to produce a semi-narcotic state (
Halbnarkose) in frogs (Santesson 1937a; Santesson 1937b)
1938 - Blas Pablo Reko and Richard Evans Schultes collect the first good voucher specimens of
coaxihuitl and ololiuhqui, identifying them definitively as
T. corymbosa (Schultes 1941). Stafford continues to obstinately insist that ololiuhqui is a
Datura species (Hoffer & Osmond 1967)
1941 - Marsh, a doctor with the US Agricultural Service bioassayed
T. corymbosa seeds. Like Reko, he found them to be inactive. It is not known whether he ground the seeds, nor is it known what quantity he consumed (Schultes 1941)
1941 - Schultes publishes an overview of the conquest-era references to ololiuhqui and the contemporary use of
T. corymbosa seeds, finally putting to rest the notion that ololiuhqui might be a
Datura species (Schultes 1941). Having now essentially stolen the fruits of Blas Pablo Reko's decades of study both on ololiuqui and teonanácatl (psilocybian mushrooms), Schultes never again returns to Mexico, shifting his focus to the visionary plants of the Amazon... Reko describes Schultes scathingly as "an ambitious young Harvard student, having turned literary pirate, [who] has taken credit for my discoveries" (Valdes 2001).
1944 - Taylor publishes another early ethnographic account of ololiuhqui use (Taylor 1944)
1945 - Reko reports observing the use of seeds from another species of bindweed,
Ipomoea violacea, among the Mazatecs (Reko 1945)
1947 – Hofmann establishes ergine (lysergic acid amide) as psychoactive at doses of 500 ug to 1 mg (primarily sedating, mildly visionary), 13 years before it’s found in the Convolvulaceae. Hofmann's experiences are basically confirmed by Solm's description of the effects nine years later (Hofmann 1961; Hofmann 1963; Solms 1956A; Solms 1956B). No visionary effect was noticed with 2 mg isoergine, only “tiredness, apathy, a feeling of mental emptiness and the unreality and complete meaninglessness of the outside world.” (Hofmann 1963)
1955 - Humphrey Osmond performs the first successful bioassay of
T. corymbosa, finding 60-100 to have visionary activity as well as substantially sedative (Osmond 1955)
1957 - Dr. Isbell (of Project MKULTRA) administers
T. corymbosa seeds to addicts at the Lexington Narcotic Farm, in doses ranging up to 6 g (about 300 seeds) but observes no significant response (Hoffer & Osmond 1967; Isbell & Gorodetzky 1966)
1958 - Two years before they're found in bindweed seeds, Yui and Takea observe elymoclavine and lysergol to produce an "excitation syndrome" in some animals (Yui & Takeo 1958 )
1959 - Kinross-Wright administers doses up to 125 seeds to eight male volunteers, and likewise does not find them to be active (Kinross-Wright 1959)
1959 - R. Gordon Wasson sends samples of
T. corymbosa and
I. violacea to Albert Hofmann, who detects the presence of indole alkaloids and asks Wasson to provide a bulk quantity of the seeds so he can characterize the active principles (Hofmann 1963; Wasson 1963)
1960 - Tómas McDougall publishes the first documentation of
I. violacea being used among the Zapotecs in essentially the same fashion as
T. corymbosa. They use the terms 'badungas' or 'badoh negro', both of which mean "black badoh". 'Badoh' is the Zapotec term for
T. corymbosa seeds (McDougall 1960)
1960 - Pérezamador and Herrán isolate a glucoside, turbicoryn, from
T. corymbosa (Pérezamador & Herrán 1960) [Turbicoryn is not believed to play any role in the psychoactive effects of the seeds]
1960 - With the help of Robert Weitlander, Irmgard Weitlander-Johnson, and Tómas MacDougall, Wasson collects 12 kg
T. corymbosa and 14 kg
I. violacea to send to Hofmann for analysis (Hofmann 1963)
1960 - By the fall of 1960, Hofmann isolates several ergot alkaloids from the seeds of both species (Hofmann 1963; Hofmann 1961; Hofmann & Tscherter 1960). This discovery is met with a great deal of skepticism; some suggest that the seeds might have been infected with ergot, others rudely suggest that the results might be compromised by the presumed presence of lysergic compounds in Hofmann's equipment from his previous work with ergot alkaloid derivatives (Hoffer & Osmond 1967; Hofmann 1980; Schultes 1972; Taber & Heacock 1962).
1961 - Though it has not yet been recognized in the seeds, Glässer finds D-Lysergic acid N-(1-hydroxyethyl) amide to have a stimulant effect in animals (Glässer 1961)
1961-1973 - Researchers find lysergic acid derivatives in numerous species in the bindweed family, Convolvulaceae (Beyerman et al. 1963; Chao & Der Marderosian 1973B; Der Marderosian 1967; Der Marderosian & Youngken 1966; Der Marderosian et al. 1964A; Der Marderosian et al. 1964B; Gardiner et al. 1965; Genest & Sahasrabudhe 1966; Hofmann 1961; Lascano et al. 1967; Ott 1996; Staba & Laursen 1966)
1962 - Cook and Kealand isolate a glucoside from
T. corymbosa; it turns out to be the already-reported turbicoryn (Cook & Kealand 1962). [Cook was a member of Project MKULTRA]
1962 - Hoffer tells Wasson that his research group had isolated ergot alkaloids from the leaves and stems of the bindweeds in quantities similar to those present in the seeds, and that they suspect ergot alkaloids to be cosmopolitan among the Convolvulaceae. Wasson writes an excited letter to Schultes and Hofmann suggesting that perhaps ololiuhqui might hold the key to the
soma mystery, in the form of a similarly psychoactive bindweed indigenous to India [note that there are many indications that the original soma was a creeper vine of some sort]. This was before Wasson had begun to work on the
soma question in earnest, and at the time he saw "no reason to think soma came from a mushroom" (Riedlinger 1993).
[Here I really have to comment. Even though just three years later it would be discovered that Argyreia nervosa (a morning glory indigenous to India) in fact contained by far the greatest concentration of ergot alkaloids, it appears Wasson never returned to this line of speculation... nor in fact has any other author considered it much (aside from a single passing sentence in Rätsch's Encyclopedia of Psychoactive Plants)... even in Riedlinger's 1993 article on Wasson's alternative soma candidates, he doesn't bother to mention A. nervosa. Personally I regard the soma problem as fundamentally insoluble, but the arguments for A. nervosa would seem to be roughly consubstantial with the other major candidates, and I see no reason why it shouldn’t be considered as a major candidate itself]1963, 1965 - Hofmann's identification of lysergic acid derivatives in bindweeds in confirmed by multiple research groups (Taber et al 1963A; Taber et al 1963B; Genest 1965)
1963 - Wasson publishes an ethnographic overview of the literature on
T. corymbosa and
I. violacea use in Mexico. It's here that he suggests Ponce's "tlitliltzin" and the reference to "ololiuhqui del moreno" that Beltrán dug up both refer to
I. violacea seeds. This is also where he suggests that all of the indigenous names that translate to "seeds of the virgin" likely refers to the virgin who grinds the seeds rather than the Virgin Mary (Wasson 1963)
1963 - Recreational use of the seeds comes on the radar in America (Shawcross 1983; Shulgin & Shulgin 1997). Herb Caen publishes an article on the subject in the San Francisco chronicle. Shulgin recalls the article in TiHKAL: "People were ordering 25 lb. sacks of seeds from whomever sold them. In the middle of May, 1963, a vice president of a major supplier, the Ferry Morse Seed Company, began to get suspicious. Although morning glory seeds were one of their five most popular items, he said, their sales had leapt to 50 times normal. The three most sought-after varieties had the unbelievable names, Heavenly Blue, Pearly Gates, and Flying Saucers." (Shulgin & Shulgin 1997)
1964, 1967 -
Ipomoea carnea, known locally as
borrachero (“inebriating one”) or
matacabra (“goat killer”) is seen to be used traditionally as an entheogen in Ecaudor, and its seeds are shown to contain ergot alkaloids (Lascano et al. 1967; Naranjo et al. 1964)
1965 – The seeds of
Argyreia nervosa (Hawaiian baby woodrose), a bindweed species with no known history of entheogenic use, are first reported to contain concentrations of lysergic acid derivatives substantially higher than any other species that has been analyzed (Chao 1970; Chao & Der Merderosian 1973A; Chao & Der Merderosian 1973B; Hylin & Watson 1965; McJunkins et al. 1968 )
1965 - Isbell and Gorodetzky found that mixtures of synthetic lysergic acid derivatives mimicked the effect of the whole alkaloid extract of
T. corymbosa, both of them differing substantially from LSD in that there was a strong sedative component to the effects (Isbell & Gorodetzky 1966)
1965-1969 - A total of 19 indole alkaloids are identified in
A. nervosa (Genest 1965; Genest 1966; Niwaguchi & Inoue 1969)
1967 - Hoffer and Osmond observe turbicoryn to show hints of activity at 30 mg (Hoffer & Osmond 1967)
1969 - Dobberstein and Staba explore ways to manipulate the alkaloid content of
A. nervosa (Dobberstein & Staba 1969)
1970s - Numerous accounts in the popular literature begin to recommend using bindweed seeds as an LSD substitute (Gottlieb 1973; Grinspoon & Bakalar 1979; Superweed 1970)
1971 - Hofmann ascertains that some of the ergine and isoergine in most bindweeds is present as the acetaldehyde adduct (N-(1-hydroxyethyl)amides) which readily hydrolyze to ergine and isoergine during the course of most extractions (Hofmann 1971)
1976 - Hofmann discovers ergonovine to be visionary on April 1, 1976, when he injests 2 mg to test the chemical basis for the ergot-Kykeon theory which he's investigating with Wasson and Ruck at the time (Hofmann 1978 ). Ott and Bigwood later confirm this finding, exploring the substance up to 10 mg (Bigwood et al 1979). Ripinsky-Naxon and colleagues likewise found 6 mg to be "entheogenic" (Ripinsky-Naxon 1993)
1976 - Furst reports that in some areas, the seeds of
T. corymbosa are prepared as a snuff.
1978-1994 - The mamas (shaman priests) of the Kogi people, who dwell in the Sierra Madre of Colombia, are reported to use
I. violacea in ritual contexts (Baumgartner 1994; Reichel-Dolmatoff 1978; Reichel-Dolmatoff 1987). While these accounts do suggest a member of the Convolvulacea, it has not been confirmed to be
I. violacea by trained botanists. Rätsch considers this identification unlikely, and suggests that it may instead be
I. carnea which is indigenous to South America (Rätsch 2005)
1979 – The Mayans are reported to know of
I. violacea as
yaxce’lil and use it in a medico-religious manner similar to the Chinantec, Mazatec, Mixtec, and Zapotec (Garza 1990; Leuenberger 1979)
1980 - Ott and Neely explore methylergonovine, finding 2 mg to be roughly equipotent with 10 mg ergonovine (Ott & Neely 1980)
1983 - Shawcross reviews the phenomenon of recreational use of Hawaiian baby wood rose seeds, and reports the experience of several individuals taking the seeds at various dosages. While undeniably psychoactive, he finds them to have substantial somatic side-effects and does not feel them to be particularly recreational (Shawcross 1983)
1985 - In addition to the medico-religious use, the Chinantec are observed to use
T. corymbosa as an ecbolic. The local term for the plant is
m’ ‘oo quiá’ sée (Browner 1985, Ortíz de Montellano & Browner 1985)
1987 - De Smet and Lipp find evidence that ololiuhqui seeds may have been administered as an enema in antiquity (De Smet & Lipp 1987)
1990, 1991 - Lipp studies the use of
I. violacea and
T. corymbosa among the Mixe. They regard the two as siblings and consider
I. violacea to be the more powerful of the two.
T. corymbosa is considered to be an apotropaic (Lipp 1990; Lipp 1991)
1992 - The elymoclavine-rich
Securidaca longipedunculata of the Polygalaceae family is reportedly used as an entheogen by the Balanta people of Guinea Bissau (Costa et al. 1992)
2002-2009 - A few modern reports of intoxication and "toxic psychosis" induced by
A. nervosa are published in the medical literature (Borsutzky et al 2002; Göpel et al 2003; Klinke et al 2009)
2010 - For the first time in the United States, the proprietor of a botanical products vendor is arrested for distributing morning glory seeds.
Well, that pretty well covers the major salient points. I tried to leave out tangential bits for the sake of brevity.