I know we had some discussion on diets before but I think it would be interesting to talk specifically about some of the common ideas/myths that show up regarding health and eating. Feel free to add any theory here so it can be discussed. Ideally people could present their own experiences, and/or some real data from reliable sources.
I'll start by just naming a few things that I hear/read often. What do you guys think of:
1- Alkaline diets - Many claims about how acidity will interfere with health, might be one of the causes of cancer, etc.
Is there any truth to this? The fact that
a - Blood has pH buffers and works on a very narrow pH range, and any significant deviation from this will generate alkalosis or acidosis which are dangerous
b- The stomach acid is composed of HCl which would neutralize and turn more acidic anything that was slightly alkaline
and
c- No publication I can find that shows any real data regarding benefits of alkaline diet
makes me think this theory is probably untrue... But maybe someone researched more to know some other facts related to this?
2- Food mixesThis seems to make a bit more sense, but dont know how far this can be taken. It seems to me reasonable to assume that certain mixes of food will improve the absorption/digestion/metabolization of certain components as opposed to other mixes. But is there any real data on what exact mixes are better or worse? Which ones are pure speculation/beliefs? For example some places will say not to mix all kinds of fruits, or that one should not mix sources of protein in a meal, or that one should not mix carbohydrates. Is there any truth to this?
3- Raw foodThe idea that raw food is always good or better than cooked food is not necessarily true.. Some raw food can be dangerous, hard to digest, or have nutrients that are not (as) bioavailable, such as for example beans (dangerous to eat raw or sprouted), potatoes (starch hard to digest raw, also dangerous due to possible toxic solanine which breaks down with heat), tomato (licopene is better absorbed when tomato is heated), etc.
Some sources:
http://ukpmc.ac.uk/abstract/MED/1432255http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/jf00106a0334- Saturated fatThe idea that saturated fat is bad persisted for long but I remember shaolin showing a meta study that denied this link. Shao can you put this up here again please?
4- MargarineSome companies sell margarine as a healthy alternative to butter. Margarine is made by hydrogenation or interesterification of plant oils. These types of modified fats are very unhealthy, as any google scholar search will show you.
Is it possible to make margarine without these processes? How can one solidify plant oils at room temperature without such chemical processes?
What else have you guys heard or are interested in talking about? Any comments on above theories/myths?