For me, you cant compare the dead to these guys, not even close enough to being the same thing to be comparable.
I took 9 grams mimosa and 4 grams of rue and listened to the new one Paper Monkeys, and Its mindblowing. Try listening to it while you are tripping..
Theres so much brilliant imagery packed in there, and the sounds are very fresh and imaginative. It is my favorite album they've done in a long time possibly my favorite album of theres ever!
There is a bit of a divide amongst ozric fans though, this much is evident. I think this is because they have 2 generations of listeners. They started as a band in the late 80's and in the early 90's produced a few of their "classic" albums including Erpland, Jurrasic Shift, Pungent Effulgent etc. The sounds were often intense and heavy in many songs including at some points thrashing metalish guitar and pounding drums with waterfall bubbles exploding all around. Alot of older ozric fans just fell in love with that heavy, sound, and as well with the guitar sound and live instruments.
Then they have there new 2000 on Spirals in Hyperspace fans who are the younger croud, who tend to be into more electronic music, than say instrumental rock. From 2000 on the sound became a bit lighter, spacier, and airier and also included much more synth programming work and programmed drums. Some may percieve this as being less intense/ psychedelic, or they dont like electronic drums, and are just into the older ozric sound.
But (and i believe this is really important) You have to hear it for yourself and form your own opinion. Reading reviews just sucks, because why read about music when you can listen yourself. Also for the reasons I stated, some people will say just what you said, "its not up there with the classics" because well they are looking for that old sound when the ozrics have moved on into a whole new direction. So its understandable that the older fans may be suprised.
But i am a fan of all of their music. Ive purchased every cd, and been through the ozric anthology, and I can honestly say in my opinion the new sound is much more refined mature and exact. Like I said every album post Waterfall Cities on (including Waterfall Cities itself) is more of a concept album than any of the stuff they did before. The tracks flow cohesively and take you on a journey into the mind and the crazy concepts Edd comes up with. There is a new vision behind each one, and I can't explain it, because its a vision painted with music not words. I believe the newer stuff to be much deeper with more layers, and indeed much more psychedelic.
Like I said Paper Monkeys is definetly in my top 3 ozric albums of all time. This album just has the energy and quality of a "comeback album". My favorites would have to be Waterfall Cities, Paper Monkeys, Yum Yum Tree, Curious Corn, and Erpland.
There are always mixed reviews and opinions about music, but it is best to ignore the reviews, and also to listen with a non-critical, but rather open and free flowing mind. You have to hear it for yourself with an fully open mind.
Also dont forget to drink some magical tea and turn the volume up loud, as actually tripping is pretty essential to being taken on a psychedelic music trip.... many seem to forget this.
You have never been apart from me. You can never depart and never return, for we are continuous, indistinguishable. We are eternal forever