inaniel wrote:It at least offers an alternative to traditional western medicine. Sugar pills don't harm people, but an estimated 225,400 people die from medical care (physician error, medication error, adverse effects from drugs or surgery) . Homeopathy may be a billion dollar industry , but traditional western medicine is a trillion dollar industry (more annually than the cost of war) and is projected to be 16 trillion by the year 2030, and despite this 15 million Americans have diabetes, half of Americans have a health problem that requires taking a prescription every week, 100 million Americans have high cholesterol. Fourteen years ago, 700,00 Americans died from heart disease, 550,000 from cancer, and 280,000 from cerebro vascular diseases. These numbers have surely risen since then. No one forces one to turn to homeopathic medicine, there is no law stating one must use it, so what is the big deal?
Many people are still dying of diseases, but never in our history have we lived so long and healthy. Medical care keeps improving.
There is no law stating that one must use homeopathy, but there is big money to be made there. If a homeopath truly believes that he is healing people, one cannot say his practice is unethical. But how can you separate these people from people who know damn well they are selling sugar for 10.000 dollars a pound? And shouldn't people be protected against misguided 'doctors', just like in regular medical care?
In the Netherlands homeopathy is included in healthcare. This means I too am paying for people taking these sugar pills.
If wealthy people are buying bottles of homeopathic pills and it makes them feel better I have no problem with that. But at some point you need to draw a line, and I think most people agree with me here. Is it ethical to use expensive homeopathy to try to cure people with terminal cancer, thereby taking the last money from desparate people? Is it ethical to go to Liberia and offer people 'treatment' for ebola with sound frequencies and magic granules (sand pills), stating that it not only cures but also prevents ebola, thereby actively helping the spread of ebola? (this is actually happening right now)
Except homeopathy fundamentalists everybody draws this line at a different moment, therefore I believe governments should take a clear stand and educate people that there is no reason to believe in homeopathic pills. Perhaps even putting a warning on the bottle, or prohibit people from selling one bottle at 3 euros and another bottle with the same sugar at 50 euros.
Then again, I'm not a big fan of neoliberalism, one could also say that this should all be left to free market and own responsibility.