Sometimes it happens that dmt doesnt crystallize well and forms an oil. Sometimes there are also small remains of naphtha trapped within this DMT oil. In either case, one solution to crystallize it would be to scrape and rescrape the oil and letting it evap/dry more, it should harden up, forming a waxy or even crystally DMT.
Considering you wanted bigger crystals though, I think your experiment probably has somewhat failed, you prob wont get any big crystals there. What you might need to do is redissolve it in small amounts of warm naphtha, put in another container and let it evap again slowly. IME a large pyrex dish is NOT the best container to form larger crystals.. Rather I think something like drinking glass might be better. You can also add a little something to act as a crystal seed, which can either be a DMT crystal you might already have from another extraction, or some kind of string, or pretty much anything with an irregular surface that doesnt dissolve in napthha.. Then you can let it evap slowly.
Alternatively, to grow crystals you can try slowly lowering the temperature of your saturated naphtha, and then alternating the container between fridge and freezer every couple of hours, which makes the smaller forming crystals keep redissolving when in the fridge and crystallizing again on top of the bigger crystals in the freezer
Hope that helps
