awooga wrote:Sure this has already been discussed but what do you think caused this to go so badly wrong?

definitely not the lye.
this particular article seems to be written intentionally vague to give it that sensationalist flair (hence the Breaking Bad scene photo) without extraneous misinformation.
seems like the spice itself (or more likely, the mushrooms) caused the man to go loopy, and alert neighbors.
the police probably fell "ill" because they either a) are afraid of chemicals, and like you implied, would have been ok with the scent of oranges, or b) were just lazy and needed an excuse to take some time off.
"Nothing is true, everything is permitted." ~ hassan i sabbah
"Experiments are the only means of attaining knowledge at our disposal. The rest is poetry, imagination." -Max Planck